Friday, June 15, 2012

Unparliamentary conduct after 2004 polls - Deputy Dewan Rakyat Speaker YB Datuk Wan Junaidi





KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia’s parliamentary culture has evolved, though not necessarily for the better.
Deputy Speaker Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar believes that the unbecoming conduct seen in MPs today stemmed from the massive influx of Barisan Nasional lawmakers into Parliament.
The lack of opposition MPs in the Dewan Rakyat, he said, led BN lawmakers to emulate their opponents in the House.
“What happened is that the culture changed during that time. BN MPs said, ‘We must speak like the opposition. We want to check the ministers’.”
“And that is the era where people like [Kinabatangan MP] Bung Mokhtar [Radin] were asking four or five ministers to resign.”
“[There were] people who made use of the language to persuade the Speaker to allow them to continue talking [in the Dewan Rakyat]. So this culture evolved into something we see today,” he told FMT in an interview in his office.
(BN won 198 seats in the 2004 election, leaving the opposition with a mere 20 seats. It was their largest vote grab to date, commanding 63.9% of the electorate.)
Wan Junaidi said this practice could be seen during Question Time, where MPs query ministers over national issues.
Wasting time
Prior to 2004 Dewan Rakyat sittings, he said that as many as 14 questions could be answered during this session.
He added that this period was increased by another 30 minutes so that Parliament could see more questions being answered.
“Every morning, we see up to 60 to 70 questions [in the Order Paper]… following what we had before, if we can reach 15 in one hour, then we can have 20-plus [with the change].”
“But in 2004, MPs started talking [but they weren't] asking questions. [They were] showing off how good they were and how well they knew [a subject],” he said.
With MPs showing off and interrupting a session, Wan Junaidi said that a lot of time was wasted.
For example, he pointed to June 13 Order Paper, which had a total of 111 questions to be answered.
However, only six questions were discussed over 90 minutes.
This culture of wasting time, Wan Junaidi said, was missing in Western Parliaments.
“If you look at England’s Parliament, their Prime Minister Tony Blair managed to answer 10 questions in half an hour,” he said.
Don’t play political card
Another problem with local MPs was their tendency to agree with their colleagues over every issue.
“You don’t agree with every MP in the Dewan Rakyat. Including the [BN] backbenchers, they’re not supposed to say yes all the time!”
“They are supposed to tell the government what is not right and correct,” he said.
At the same time, he said that an MP should not always go against a government’s view.
“You have to listen to the government’s explanation as well, and not just continue to say your [view] is right and the other’s is wrong.”
“…The whole idea of MPs who are not holding portfolios [in the government] is to put the government to account on whatever they do.”
“That is their responsibility as an MP,” he said, adding that an MP needed to refrain from playing the emotional or political card.
But most important of all, Wan Junaidi said that Malaysian MPs needed to respect each others’ opinions, even if they did not agree with them.
Every MP, he added, had the right to be heard.
“While you dare to say something, you must also dare to listen to what others say. It may be contrary to your belief.”
“…[An MP might say] I don’t like to listen, [but] that’s why they say, ‘I hate to hear what you [have to] say [but I'd] die to preserve the right [for you] to do it.’”
“That is democracy,” he said.

Freemalaysiatoday interview

36 comments:

  1. Suko chak tuk melago-lago sidak tubong tuk

    ReplyDelete
  2. Apa kata ktk pok sik ada org melago lago org tubong baca low brk beri komen pok

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very professional comment.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kita tambah ramei lagi yb pkr dlm dewan rakyat supaya yb bn makin gelabah,padan muka bn!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Siapa suroh bn pilih org tak berkualiti jadi yb hasilnys jadilsh yb bn yb bodo dlm dewan.buksn salah yb pr.rakyat akan pilih yb pr mkn ramai dlm pru 13 nanti.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yb bn berbudibahasa yb pr kurang ajar lah pok mcm u pok

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Berbudi bahasa maksudnya bisu x berani mengutara apa2 dlm sidang. betul2 cuma nak manas tempat duduk ajak! anggok bila disuruh dan bangkang bila diperintah!

      Delete
  7. Yg salah rakyat yg ngundi sidak tuk dan jdlah yb di Parlimen yg bisu dan merapu sepanjang masa !Tangar dolok sapa yg kurang ajar! Udah ktk cek dlm Hansard?

    ReplyDelete
  8. MP Bn semo belukuk kerana makin banyak Mangkok Ayun...Bagus MP kito Batang Ayun...Mun Pantat iboh jak jadi MP ...Makai Puki..
    so Ambik Batang jadi MP baruk leehai maa.MP quota dah cukup sidak Mangkok Ayun...Ambik jak Batang Belian....sik iboh makan Pantat agik..DWJ ..MOST LEEHAI MP DARI MP DAK MANGKOK...UUUU

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nancy,Rohani &Nora all Mangkok Ayun MP! Bagus gilak sidak tuk kah ???All sik nguna Orang Pbb & Nancy ngelai Wan Wahab:Rohani ngelai Julai & Simoi..Nora pun samo cos Debei Bertemu Jako jegem Len Talip..Yen Susah angai Amero gak jadi MP..Susah lah kito ERECTION PRU TUK KELAK...CARI JAK BUTOH BELIAN PAKEI MADAT SIDAK MP MANGKOK TUK ..HUH HEH HEH KAH KAH KAH

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. APOLAH NAK DI KATO ...MANGKOK AYUN JADI MP .KELAK SIDAK PKR ,PAS ,DAP NGAYUN SIDAK MPUAN YO .BANYAK VIAGRA DAH DI IMPORT OLIH SIDAK PAKATAN ROKET PAKEI MBANTEI SIDAK MANGKOK =MAK JANDA ,MAK SIK JANDA ==AYUN JAK SAMPEI PAGI . HUH HAH....NGAP SAYOT SIDAK MP YO .BAGUS NAR SIDAK MANGKOK AYUN TUK DI TUKAR DGN SIDAK BATANG BATANG UGAK BELIAN -CIKGU RAILI NGANTI NANCY ,YUSUP BUJI NGANTI MAK JANDA BTG LONGGAR DAN USTAZ KIPLI YASIN MGANTI NORA TUN RAHMAN.NYAK IYA.

      Delete
    2. APOLAH NAK DI KATO ...MANGKOK AYUN JADI MP .KELAK SIDAK PKR ,PAS ,DAP NGAYUN SIDAK MPUAN YO .BANYAK VIAGRA DAH DI IMPORT OLIH SIDAK PAKATAN ROKET PAKEI MBANTEI SIDAK MANGKOK =MAK JANDA ,MAK SIK JANDA ==AYUN JAK SAMPEI PAGI . HUH HAH....NGAP SAYOT SIDAK MP YO .BAGUS NAR SIDAK MANGKOK AYUN TUK DI TUKAR DGN SIDAK BATANG BATANG UGAK BELIAN -CIKGU RAILI NGANTI NANCY ,YUSUP BUJI NGANTI MAK JANDA BTG LONGGAR DAN USTAZ KIPLI YASIN MGANTI NORA TUN RAHMAN.NYAK IYA.

      Delete
  10. Makin sidak yb adun bn semua longgar utak nak mlawan yb dap.terhaler haler yb adun bn nak mlawan yb dap.,idup pkr.makin yb dolah saidol kaki botol terhaler haler nak mlawan WONG HO LENG lpas kenak tikam file landsurvey.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dollah Saidol adalah YB yang di groomed untuk JADI FUTURE MENTERI . KESIAN YB ABU SEMAN sampei hati TOK JANGGUT SIK PUSH NYA JADI CHAIRMAN BACKBENCHER atau JADI KETUA SETIAUSAHA POLITIK -YB ABU SEMAN SUPOL YG MOST HARDWORKING MAA.MUN ABU SEMAN JADI BACKBENCHER CHAIRMAN ,PEMBANGKANG SEMUA CABUT LARI KERANA YB ABU AKAN NERAIS SIDAK NYA DENGAN SUARA EMASNYA HEH HEH

      Delete
    2. SETUJU NAR AKU ABU JADI BACKBENCHER CHAIRMAN ,LAGI LEEHAI LAH DUN KITO COS TOK JANGGUT GENG KERAS ABU SEMAN .YB KARIM PUN SIK NGOKOK MUN ABU SEMAN JADI BACKBENCHER CHAIRMAN .HUH HAH GOHET JAK YB ABU ,POCO POCO SAMPEI PAGI

      Delete
    3. YB ABU NAN AKU SOKONG BAH ,DAH DUA TERM JADI SUPOL DAN ADUN TETAPI MASIH JUAK TINGGAL BAS !!!!POCO POCO JAK YB ABU SAMPEI PAGI ,TENGAH HARI ,MAGRIB DAN JAM 12 malam.SABAR JAK ABU !!!!!

      Delete
    4. macam ini nak jadi menteri mun masih suka poco2..ketinggalan zaman dan YB Abu yea...

      Delete
    5. Abu ya nunggu nak di tikam sidak matu keluar. Cuma Bos sidak Matu/Daro masih kesian ajak.Nyawanya ya nyawa ikan jak.

      Delete
  11. Sabar yb abu, agi bagus yb abu ya pok mun yb ripin lamet lekenya meruntuh rumahtangga orang mun kmk d miri nang tahu hal yb rpn suykur kt rakyat swk nya sik jd menteri muda ari ya mun nya jadi pakai seluar dlm besi aja bini bini kt semua hdp pkr hdp parti islam semalaysia

    ReplyDelete
  12. Haha pok jaga jaga oreng kadayan ya pakai ilmu hitam nya hentam u xyb adin wing kwsn bekanu di rampasnya cm pun sik dpt menpertahankan yb adn uth d calon semula jaga jaga penduduk sebuti. ????SIAPA KAH MANGSA YB BN YANG AKAN D HITAM OLE YB RPN LAMAT RAJA BOMOH ILAMU HITAM

    ReplyDelete
  13. Sik apa pok nang uda kt dmiri tahu nya pun perangai pakai bomoh kmk dengar masa tuk nya kehulu khilir lobi nembiak nama dato safri asal kuching untuk jadi calon sebuti tapi perangai sama aja seperti yang bohong ripin lamat jaga jaga aja bini kt orang hidup pekatan rakyat

    ReplyDelete
  14. Wan Junaidi dikenal org Tubong ngan bahaso Datuk Wan manas ngan YB Azmin Ali bilo YB Azmin nyebut sik demokratik. Lalu Si Wan sik guno tuk ngampit org Swak. Kato nyo jgn mandang rendah ngan org Swak. Org Semenanjung sik iboh campor hai n ngasut org Swak. Mako nyo emoun turun nait belon pegi Semenanjung. Madah ngan org Malaya nun jgn masuk campor hai di Swak. Pembantu Khas YB Azmin sik dibena masok Swak. Kononnya, koso mutlak kerajaan negeri Swak ngikut 20 Perkaro Swak nubuh samo2 negaro Malaysia. Yo pun Si Wan tuk ngato "Perjanjian Swak masuk Malaysia". Bukan perjanjian masok Malaysia Si Wan oi, yo perjanjian samo2 nubuh Malaysia. Si Wan tuk butak sejarah. Mun hai org Malaya masuk Swak, lorah nyebut perjanjian yo. Yo tandonyo palak org politik Swak tuk, sidak PBB masih bepikir caro lamak. Mala jak madah ikut perjanjian yo. Sebab yo palak sidak nyo bekuk, sik tebukak. Mun macam yo, semoa sidak dari Malaya sik dibena ninjak tanah Swak tuk. Sik kiro sapo, sapo2 jak dari Malaya nun. Palak Si Wan tuk betuk. Kau empun yo Si Wan nyilat burit sidak org politik BN dari Malaya nun. Apo bezo si keparat sidak BN dari Malaya nun ngan org lain. Ni 1Malaysia nak disokong BN/PBB Swak lamak tuk. Cakap jak besa, eko bisik taik. Macam manok. Patut YB2 BN/PBB Swak tuk macam manok kenak kungo bilo dtg ke Parlimen. Pengecut nak becakap ttg kepentingan Swak. Angut2 macam terontang. Aok jak apo kenak buli BN dari Malaya nun. Konon pejuang kepntingan Swak. Muko ko diat. Sapo sik tauk Si Wan tuk. Iboh cakap besa gilak. Tungu kau kalah election klak. Berak kapor kau Si Wan.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Pok pok diri nang hebat benar kato diri ya nang patut pbb tukar wj dng wan hamzar mun kmk diat wan hamzar nang mati mati mahu jd calon nubong sbb wj memamg bodor mun kt PR sik akan milih calon mcm wj

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. kitak org pkr nang bodor..ya lah ko milih pkr..pati bodor...pkr bodo..pkr bodo..pkr bodo..

      Delete
  16. sikk peduli pok..wj kah, whamzah kah, drahman jaladin kah, draup kah..kmk orh pkr akan tetap lawan!!!!!IDUP PKR!!!IDUP PKR!!! TUMBANGKAN SEMUA CALON PBB!!!!LAWAN TETAP LAWAN.

    ReplyDelete
  17. nakpanama dikecoh2 ktk org pkr ngan pbb d sitok..tunggu ajaklah election tok baru tauk sapa menang sapa kalah...ndak iboh mcm manok berkokok rioh sekampung bah.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Haha marah orang pbb mun kt calon pbb pakai nama diripun untuk bertanding melwn kmk pkr cubalah kali tuk jangan makei nama ketua menteri dn keluarga utk berkempan belum tahu kt orang pbb menang kerusi tubong diat kt orang kat kawasan bandar kuching SUPP kmk PR simpan meiw (puasa) pun boleh menang sbb orang cina d bandar2 seluruh Sarawak memang benci dng km kt orang dn keluarga2nya bah hidup pkr oh oh

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. minta maap pok..sikada org pbb bertanding makei nama keluarga dato taib ya..semua org pbb btanding makei nama PBB dan BN, bahkan dato taib ya empun bertanding makei nama PBb dan tiket BN.nang sik tauk hulu hilir ko tok pok.

      Delete
    2. kitak urg pbb tok lah bodoh sik berakal takot dgn dato taip sik tentu pasal.kitak urg ingat dato taip ya menang dlm pilihanraya kah mun sik kerana lambang BN dan lambang PBB yg dipakeinya.Mun taip rasanya koat glak cubalah bertanding makei lambang nya empun sik pedulilah lambang ikan emas kah, lambang CMS kah, lambang Persatuan Melano kah, lambang kayu balakkah, cubalah sia.barulah dato taip ya tauk samada nya koat kah sik...jaoohhhhhh pakawieeeeeee mun taip ya dapat menang.selamak tok nya numpang kekuatan lambang BN ajak tapi kitak urg pbb jak yg bodoh sik sedar2...masih juak ketakutan ngan taip.

      Delete
  19. nak pa dikerepak kau tok ngok???paham ko nak pa ditulis ko ya???aku sik paham nakpa idea yg nak dipadah ko tok??atau kao tok ajiz denan yg dah anggol kompius dlm perangkap yg dipolah kau empun.kotan banyak glak watak yg direka oleh kau dlm sebanaku tok akhirnya kau empun dah sik tauk siapa kau dlm tok...mcm org gila dah ko tok ajis denan..nang juak kau dah gila.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kitak tuk apa nak d geram gilak n phobia ngan ajiz ya? Nya ada berutang ngan ktk kah, ngaco anak bini kluarga ktk? Rame orng situk x ada kaitan ngan aiz ya moleh komen. Yg kmk tau situk x ada pun ajiz ya brkomen! Mun geram pg jumpa ajiz baru gentleman Pok!

      Delete
  20. Pok pok udah hbs model. Lah u ya baguslah mcm ya kempan pru tuk kmk pkr mahu u dlm pbb hentam aja km dn keluarga2 nya dn anak2 saudaranya teruskan pok bersama pr .udah u baca utusan borneo dn borneo post hari tuk 19.6.12 muka4 (ub) dn (bp) bukan kmk org pkr sik tahu siapa u pok bermuka muka dsatok ya hdp pkr

    ReplyDelete
  21. Pande na ktk urg carik info sampe lubang cacing tok oooh, cuba madah lok sak kmk urg senang carik pasal pkr kah o dap kah... Lagik berpaedah.... Cuba tak urf baca balit komen2. Ktak urg tuk org pkr kah ato org pbb? Nang nak bunuh antara dirik jak, pas ya berpuak2! Tuk soalan cepumas bagi tak urg yg pake bahasa yg indah lagi bait tok ah... Yang ktk urg nyokong boss boss tak urg tuk bunoh org lain ya... Mikir dolok, bila boss tak urg sik guna tak urg lagik.. Jangan terkezut bila tak urg pulak akan di bante klak mcm ajiz denan tok.... Hahhahahah tak urg sik tauk... Kalau ati urg jaik... Tak urg tuk pake guna nya ajak... Bila sik di guna lagik, ngorek lah tak urg lubang cacing, lubang sampah... Ato mana2 lubang ... Jaga dirik bagus gik dr jaga boss tak urg yg sik guna ya... Hehehe....

    ReplyDelete
  22. Nampak gaya Ip add yg. Salu fitnah dn ejek ajis tok dtg dr pej.petra jaya jln astana. Fadilla bin yusuf atau fazarudin bin abd rahman berkerja obertaim tuk Fitnah ajis denan.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Saudara2 kmk uda selalu beri peringatan dng semua penulis dlm blog2 tuk jangan melampuh batas kita semua ada ip kt beri info bukan memfitna info mst betuk jng sempai kt masuk penjara kerana mahu menjatuh kan seseorang janganlah sempai menhina mak bapa keturunan fikirlah sebelum menulis lebih lebih lagi peminpin negeri,kerluarga mereka tanpa asas dn bukti ,dlm tuk telalu byk pekatan ugutan kpd seseorang ,caci mencaci,fitna menfitna sesiapa yng berani buat bertanggunjawaplah jika kt akan d dtgi oleh pihak berkuasa POLIS sediahlah terimalah belasan dr allah swt

    ReplyDelete
  24. wan hamzah main politik wang,berik projek sama dirik ajak,jadi kambing hitam jak u pok

    ReplyDelete